New Village Pizza

Discover New Village Pizza in Indianapolis for delicious, affordable pizza, subs, breadsticks, Philly cheesesteaks, and more. Conveniently located at 2002 N Arlington Ave. Call +1 317-359-0500 for lunch or dinner!

Welcome to New Village Pizza

Taste the Difference.

New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza

Nestled at 2002 N Arlington Ave, Indianapolis, New Village Pizza serves a simple yet satisfying menu that attracts pizza lovers and hungry neighbors alike. This cozy spot combines affordable prices with hearty portions, making it a beloved joint in the community. With each slice, patrons find a taste of home, whether it’s classic cheese or specialty pizzas.

The atmosphere buzzes with friendliness and chatter, ideal for families, friends, and anyone needing a quick bite. Known for its welcoming vibe, New Village Pizza is more than just a dining spot—it's a gathering place where good food creates great connections.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

2002 N Arlington Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218, United States

Phone

+1 317-359-0500

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza
New Village Pizza

Founded with a commitment to quality and affordability, New Village Pizza has established itself as a cornerstone of the Indianapolis community. The pizzeria maintains a clear mission: deliver delicious meals that fit every budget. From fresh ingredients to generous servings, they provide an authentic pizza experience without compromise. Each recipe reflects the care and passion behind it, appealing to both classic and adventurous eaters.

While pizzas shine as the main attraction, the menu offers much more.

The Alaskan Pollock and Dave's Fried Bologna Sandwich highlight a variety of grilling options, showcasing versatility in their culinary offerings. Customers often share their favorites on social media, creating a community of food enthusiasts, eager to recommend hidden gems like potato wedges and breadsticks. These have become iconic choices, often highlighted by delighted diners in local reviews.

The restaurant's history reveals a dedication not just to food, but to community ties.

Regular patrons feel at home here, and it’s not uncommon for newcomers to experience an instant warm welcome. As friends gather over meals, stories are exchanged—fostering an unmistakable camaraderie that makes New Village Pizza much more than just a meal stop. With every order, the restaurant nurtures this sense of belonging, ensuring each individual feels valued. So, stop by and get a taste of what makes this local favorite so special.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-11 PM
  • Monday4-11 PM
  • Tuesday4-11 PM
  • Wednesday4-11 PM
  • Thursday4-11 PM
  • Friday4-11 PM
  • Saturday4-11 PM

New Village Pizza boasts an impressive menu that caters to various tastes without breaking the bank. Popular items include their tenderloin and Philly cheese steak, which locals rave about. Those craving appetizers can enjoy crispy potato wedges or breaded mushrooms, perfect for sharing. With an average price of just $4.60, it’s clear why this pizzeria continues to draw in a steady stream of customers. The menu isn't extensive, but it’s designed to satisfy hunger without overwhelming decisions.

The restaurant also features a delightful selection of drinks, including Pepsi, adding the perfect touch to any meal.

Customers can enjoy their food on-site or take it to go—it’s a favorite among busy locals making evening commutes. The friendly staff enhances the experience, ensuring that each visit feels personal.

New Village Pizza

From the outside, New Village Pizza presents a charming facade that invites passersby to explore its delicious offerings. Bright signage proudly displays the pizzeria's name, while large windows provide a sneak peek into the bustling atmosphere within. The location, just off a major road, is convenient for quick stops or leisurely visits.

The outdoor area invites customers to enjoy the fresh air while savoring their favorite dishes. Whether taking a seat outside for a quick lunch or grabbing a slice on the go, the vibe remains relaxed and friendly. This casual setting promotes community connections, making it a favored spot among locals.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

One of the better pizzas that I've had in a long time.

T
Trent W.

amazing little side shop. PIZZA IS AMAZING !! Village special thin. I travel all over this country and eat a lot of pizza . This place is in the top 3

W
William K.

We ordered around the world pizza and it was very good, fresh and hot!!

A
Andrea D.

Friendly staff and Amazing food!!!!! The salad was out of this world.... Lots of food for the price too....

S
Sara W.

Great food, but with this economy. It's really put the boot on these guys. Next, you know. How do I say they had the razor price so much that I can't even afford it. It's hard to explain it's once a month thing. When it used to be once a week thing. It just doesn't make sense. With this great economy. We have, but the food is amazing. People inside are old school very respectful. A great place to eat with the price of it is just little over the edge for what it is.

z
zombielover317able

This little gem is so good! Was looking for pizza that delivered to my area because I live far from everything. Not only did they deliver but the driver forgot my Pepsi and went to the gas station and bought me another one. I decide i wanted another pizza so i went again. This time I drove down and met the owners. A sweet little couple that now I call mama and dad! This is a great family pizza shop.! If ever in the area give them a try!

A
Alicia S.